Blog | See Insights on Luxury Home Building & Remodeling | E Builders

Should Utah Homeowners Remodel, Build a New Home, or Move in 2025?

Written by E Builders - Luxury Custom Home Builder | Apr. 14, 2025

 

Deciding on Remodeling, Building, or Moving

Utah’s housing market is booming, and homeowners like you face a major decision: Should you remodel, move, or build a new home? Rising Utah property values and high demand mean that all three options have pros and cons. Whether you want to maximize your investment, create a custom space, or find a new home in a different area, it’s essential to weigh the financial and lifestyle factors carefully.

This guide breaks down the benefits and drawbacks of remodeling, moving, and new construction while considering the housing market and how the average home price in Utah affects your options. 

Pros and Cons of Renovation vs. New Construction

Cost is always a major factor in deciding whether to renovate or build new. The average home price in Utah continues to rise, making remodeling attractive if you want to improve your current space without entering a competitive market. However, building a new home allows for full customization. Let’s look at both options.

The best parts of remodeling

The impact these factors have on you will help you determine whether you should remodel, move, or even build a new custom home. You may even find elements of remodeling that you love that aren't listed here. This is just to provide an idea.

Remodeling Pros

  • Cost: Is renovating or buying a new house cheaper? The cost of renovating a home is usually more affordable than purchasing or building a new home. You can also pinpoint what precisely you want to change.
  • Higher Home Value: Strategic upgrades can boost your Utah home's property value, leading to a higher resale price. Remodeling also adds intrinsic value to your home, making it more enjoyable to live there.
  • No Need to Move: If you love your location, renovation avoids the stress of finding a new home. You don't have to trade neighbors and conveniences you love for a new setting.
  • Customized Upgrades: You can make meaningful improvements without starting from scratch. One of the benefits of remodeling is that you can tailor your existing home to you.

The opposing view

Every pro has its con, and we don't want to send you to remodeling without pointing out some of the downsides associated with renovating.

The Cons of Remodeling

  • Unexpected Expenses: Old homes can hide expensive surprises like electrical or plumbing issues. Your budget is a major part of whether or not you should remodel your home.
  • Limited Layout Changes: Major structural modifications can be costly and complicated. If you have a two-story home and want a single-story home, renovating would still not make sense. 
  • Temporary Inconvenience: Living through construction can be stressful and disruptive. The timeline and disruption involved in remodeling can be a big factor in renovating vs. moving. 

The highlights of building 

Building a new custom home can be exciting, and there is so much to consider. It's easy to get excited about the new, shiny parts of building a custom home, but there is so much more to enjoy.

Building Pros

  • Complete Customization: Every detail of your home is designed to fit your lifestyle. If you build a custom home, every feature is your choice.
  • Energy Efficiency: New homes feature modern materials that lower utility costs. From the windows to the shape of the walls, you can save money and energy in a new home.
  • Fewer Repairs: With brand-new features, maintenance costs are minimal. You also don't have to renovate part of a new-to-you house that doesn't fit you. 

downsides of a new build

We promised to present both sides of the argument always. We don't want to sell you on building a new custom home without acknowledging that there can be downsides. 

A Few Cons

  • Cost: Building your own custom home in Utah is not inexpensive, and luxury customization can add to that cost. You need to be sure it's the right choice for your family and your budget. 
  • Timeline: Custom homes take time, requiring months of planning, construction, and finishing up. The process of building a custom home is a long-term commitment.
  • Land Availability: Finding a good lot in a desirable area can be challenging. While Utah doesn't have the land shortage that other states do, the best lots still go quickly. 

If you’re wondering if remodeling is worth it, the answer depends on your remodeling budget and goals. Renovating may be a wise investment if your current home is in good condition. However, building new might be more practical if you need major structural changes.

Is Moving the Right Choice?

We've discussed whether you should remodel or build, but what about building? Selling your home and moving may be the best decision if your current home no longer meets your needs. However, moving has advantages and challenges.

When it makes sense

Moving can feel overwhelming, but sometimes, it can be the simplest option. You can add other reasons to your list, but here are just a few ideas.

Moving Pros

  • More Space or Better Layout: If your home feels too small or isn’t functional, moving allows you to find a space that better fits your lifestyle.
  • New Location: Moving allows you to relocate to an area with better schools, amenities, or a shorter commute.
  • Costs: If your home requires costly updates, selling and buying something move-in-ready may be more cost-effective.

When it doesn't make sense 

Moving tends to have a bad reputation, so you likely don't have to think hard about the tough parts. However, each one depends on your situation.

The Cons

  • Home Prices: The average home price in Utah has increased, meaning you’ll likely pay more for a new home. This will not be an inexpensive endeavor. If you don't find the perfect house, you may be paying more to renovate it after you buy it.
  • Competitive Market: Utah's housing market is highly competitive, making it challenging to find the perfect home while still dealing with high prices. You may be paying more than you initially budgeted for the right house.
  • Right Place: It can be difficult to find the perfect home that doesn't need any renovations. Often, homeowners move only to discover that they want to remodel their new home.

If you're considering moving, research Utah property values and market trends to make an informed decision. Only you can decide if now is a good time for you to move.

Trending: Salt Lake City

Is Salt Lake City growing or shrinking? The answer is clear: It’s growing. Thousands of people move to Salt Lake City every year, drawn by its strong economy, outdoor lifestyle, and high quality of life.

Why are so many people moving to Utah? There are various reasons, some large-scale and some personal, but we've compiled some of our favorite reasons below.

Reasons Why People Are Moving to Utah

With more people moving in, Utah property values continue to rise, making real estate a solid investment. Let's look at a few reasons why people are choosing this state. 

1. Booming Tech Industry

Utah’s "Silicon Slopes" attract tech professionals nationwide. The area is growing and thriving as more high-achievers become residents. 

2. Outdoor Recreation

Skiing, hiking, and national parks make Utah a desirable place to live. Plus, who wouldn't love living with breathtaking views in sight every single day?

3. Safe Communities

Utah is known for its family-friendly neighborhoods and low crime rates. No matter where you live in the state, you can find a safe space for your family. 

Whether you choose to remodel, move, or build new, understanding Utah’s growth patterns will help you make the best decision for your future.

Working with E Builders

E Builders is Utah’s trusted partner for luxury home renovations and custom homes for various reasons, not just our beautiful gallery of projects.

Our reputation has been built on delivering expert craftsmanship backed by years of experience and our process, which guarantees every project is of exceptional quality. Our strong relationships with top tradespeople allow us to offer stable and competitive pricing, providing consistent value for our clients.

Contact Us

If you choose to move, you'll need a real estate agent. However, if you're investing in a remodel or building a new home in our service area of Utah, you'll need a team like ours at E Builders.

Contact us today for a consultation. Your dreams and goals await.